Shabbos Zachor Poem 5780

Considering that everyone is feeling some anxiety,

I’ve been back and forth internally debating the propriety,

Of whether I should still speak this Shabbos in verse  form,

But I worried that if I cancelled due to panic and to craziness,

I would be helping not at all, and just reveal my laziness

So just your crummy luck, I still decided to perform

But the question I had faces us, how can a Jew rejoice,

And celebrate Purim the year with a hearty voice,

While so many of our brethren are closed off in quarantine?

In Switzerland and Italy, France or Israel,

At YU or SAR or the Young Israel of New Rochelle,

Purim has been ruined for so many by the COVID-19

And if we are believing Jews who place our faith in God,

Who does not act capriciously, is the timing of this odd,

Is there a message in this illness that we need to discern?

Or is this just how nature works and how the cookie crumbles,

Disease will spread, when helped along by administrative fumbles,

And we just have to pray that it never is our turn?

Rav Soloveitchik taught a teaching that’s well founded in the sources,

Often in the context of his famous public discourses,

That resonates for me considering what’s happening these days,

We’re not God’s accountants, and it’s therefore quite heretical

To invent reasons for calamities, be they natural or medical,

As it implies we are the confidants who know God’s hidden ways

But we can always look around at the world and reflect,

At parts of our character that we still need to perfect 

That’s a sign of sensitivity, and for that there is a place

And indeed, I have been reflecting and I thought of an idea

Emerging from the history of persia and medea,

Concerning Haman’s twisted hatred against the Jewish Race

In his attempt to rally Achashverosh to his side

As he laid out his agenda perpetrating genocide,

He said the Jews were awful and incredibly pernicious,

Spread in every country throughout the king’s dominion,

They followed their own laws and so he stated his opinion,

they must be dealt with in a manner both definitive and vicious

The Hebrew word “Yeshno” is the word that Haman uses

It means, “there is” and thus began his terrible abuses

But the Talmud renders this in a very different pronunciation, 

“Yashnu” is the way in which the Talmud reads this word,

A horrible indictment, everywhere that it was heard,

It meant that we were sleeping, and was quite a denunciation

This word, which clearly indicates that Haman had our number,

Catsgiates us for it shows we demonstrated slumber,

As we went through our religious lives with nothing more than rote,

And in it there’s a reference to the hebrew word “yashan,” 

Which means that we were old and that our passion  was long gone,

It had been too long since we had had accomplishments of note

Haman’s words were a wakeup call that we needed some direction,

To rise up from our torpor and strengthen our divine connection,

To act with purpose, not just to move through life as though instinctive,

To be a Jew on autopilot is not at all the way to act,

And so when Haman rose against us we had to react,

In a manner that was different, and especially distinctive

As opposed to earlier when we joined the royal bashes,

We cried out to the heavens wrapped in sackcloth and in ashes,

For salvation from the man whose plan every single Jew despised,

Because we were willing to break away from our standard practice,

We were ready to respond when the Persian bands attacked us,

Suddenly our connection to our God was energized

I think this message resonates as we contemplate the spread

Of a disease that is less serious than the attendant fear and dread, 

Because it causes us to think about what we normally ignore

How many times a day we bring our hands up to our faces,

Or shake each others’ hands and go to different filthy places,

I’m fairly certain most of us didn’t think of this before,

So now that circumstances force us to be a little wary,

Of matters of our hygiene and that which is sanitary,

Perhaps we should look inward, and beyond our physicality,

And give some thought to the sum total of our spiritual existence,

Which is so often rote along the path of least resistance,

And approach our sacred lives with the same level of intentionality

I want to make it clear that  I am not at all desirous,

Of minimizing the extent of the spread of the coronavirus

But we must not go crazy  as we move about our lives

We can have a joyous Purim by using more Purell,

Let us follow precautions and please God we’ll all stay well,

Especially if we refrain from our usual Shabbat Shalom high-fives.

But Churchill said “Never let a crisis go to waste,”

So let us not forget now that even in our haste,

We can use this illness as a chance to do more than just cleaning

And as we wash our hands for 20 seconds per the Drs. recommendation,

Let us think of ways to cleanse ourselves and foster motivation,

Thinking more about what we do to fill our souls with meaning

And may these lessons last for us even when the scare abates,

Because this virus teaches us the mingling of our fates,

We all have the ability to connect to many others,

So may our intentionality and personal improvement,

Be equally contagious and turn into a movement,

And may this Purim be a joyous, healthy one for our sisters and our brothers

©2020 Rabbi Ariel Rackovsky

Stolen Signals, Lessons Learned

This weekend, Parshat Shemot, marked 5 years since the weekend we came to try out for the Rabbinic position at Shaare Tefilla. During the interview process and, thank God, subsequent relocation, I conducted extensive research about Dallas and quickly learned of the vehement civic rivalry between our city and Houston. Without rehashing tired tropes and perpetuating stereotypes, I’m certain that recent baseball news out of Houston was met here with a great deal of Dallasite schadenfreude. For those who are too busy with Daf Yomi or Nach Yomi to follow baseball, here is a basic outline of the facts:

At the end of the 2019 season, Mike Fiers, a former Astros pitcher, told journalists from The Athletic that the Astros stole signs delivered by the catcher to the pitcher throughout that season. This behavior is not inherently prohibited in baseball; players do it all the time. Indeed, the unwritten rules of baseball- lehavdil, the Torah shebe’al Peh– state that this is permitted under certain circumstances, so long as certain conventions are observed, such as a batter not peeking at the signs of a catcher. In the Torah shebichtav, the Rules of Baseball, it is prohibited to use any mechanical device to record signs. Fiers alleged that the Astros used technology to steal the opposing team’s signs, and through an elaborate, evolving, player-driven system, relayed them to the batter. As a result, Major League Baseball conducted a thorough investigation and suspended GM Jeff Luhnow and manager A.J. Hinch, prohibiting them from all contact with baseball for a year; they were subsequently fired by the Astros, who also were fined $5 million and had to forfeit their first- and second-round picks in 2020 and 2021. Many (read: Dodgers and Yankees fans) feel that this punishment is insufficient, as it does not involve the restoration of the title to the Dodgers or the relinquishment of their World Series win. Furthermore, a $5 million fine for a baseball team is the equivalent of pocket change. Since breaking, the scandal has radiated out to other teams. Alex Cora, the mastermind behind this scheme, was implicated in similar behavior while managing the 2018 Red Sox, who immediately announced that they were parting ways with him. Carlos Beltran, recently hired by the Mets as manager, was implicated for his role as a player, and rapidly became another casualty. Other players have since been dogged by allegations that they were wearing wires during games.  But while everyone else piles on the Astros, I think I understand them- based on the central dialogue in this week’s Parshah.  

This week, we are introduced to Moshe, whose presence as the leader of the Jewish people will loom large throughout the rest of the Torah. But Moshe strongly resists God’s call to leadership, for two different reasons. First, Pharaoh would not listen to him; there was nothing special about him, no redeeming qualities that would arrest the attention of a powerful potentate. 

Exodus 3:11

But Moses said to God, “Who am I that I should go to Pharaoh and free the Israelites from Egypt?”

And quite aside from Pharaoh, whom Moshe would have to confront to secure the liberation of the Jews, it was the Jews themselves Moshe felt unworthy of leading. 

But Moses said to the LORD, “Please, O Lord, I have never been a man of words, either in times past or now that You have spoken to Your servant; I am slow of speech and slow of tongue.”

Why was he worried about failing on both fronts? Because Moshe possessed a speech impediment that rendered him inarticulate. Perhaps he slurred or swallowed his words; perhaps he stuttered. Some commentaries, the like Rashbam, suggest that he was simply not fluent in the language. Many commentaries ask a simple question: If God is all-powerful and could cause a previously healthy hand to become infected with tzaraat, if God could turn water into blood and a staff into a crocodile- why couldn’t he cure Moshe’s speech defect? Indeed, the Daat Zekeinim even describes this as Moshe’s intent in resisting God. “Do you want me to carry out your mission? Then cure me first.”

The answer to this question is in God’s response to Moshe. 

And the LORD said to him, “Who gives man speech? Who makes him dumb or deaf, seeing or blind? Is it not I, the LORD?  Listen to a remarkable explanation from Rabbeinu Yosef Bechor Shor:

God said to Moshe, “If I wanted to, I would have cured you already, or I would not have afflicted you with this speech impediment in the first place. But the real glory to God comes about when a person with no mouth and no tongue fulfills my words and completes my desires, and will accomplish great things. “

God was telling Moshe that the greatest kiddush Hashem would come about through someone who, in ordinary circumstances, might be pitied, viewed as a nebbach. He possessed no administrative skills, no personal magnetism and  completely lacked the gift for soaring oratory. He lacked confidence, and was not a corporate leader who could command a board room. If that kind of person could lead a nation and defy a dictator, what a miracle that would be! The secret of Moshe’s success was that he did not require these skills, because, as a shepherd of his flock, his role was psychological. He commanded respect and led his nation through his deep caring and his uncompromising authenticity. If that’s the case, why did Moshe resist the call to service? He should have been reassured by God’s choice of him that he was perfect for the job! I think Moshe resisted  because he understood why he was chosen.

But he said, “Please, O Lord, make someone else Your agent.”

Find someone else, whose authentic self this role expresses, to be your agent. As the Sforno explains, Moshe challenged God to use someone already naturally gifted for such an assignment, instead of someone who required on the job training and who was not an intuitive fit for the job. Moshe realized the daunting responsibility of leading a community in this way, when his role was to fulfill the psychological and emotional needs of an entire nation, and he felt  that being a leader like this was not an expression of his true self. 

There is no question that the Astros cheated throughout the entire 2017 season, the culmination a several year tear-down and rebuild of the franchise. And they did so out of venality, through the desire for unearned glory and ill-gotten gains. Permit me, however, to offer the following not as a defense, but as a charitable explanation. Recall that in the final third of that season, Houston was ravaged by Hurricane Harvey. So many Astros fans were bereft of their property and possessions, and faced the lengthy and soul-crushing process of rebuilding their homes at best. Houstonians needed a win, and they made the Astros the repository for all their hopes and aspirations. If the Astros could win their first World Series ever, particularly in that year, everything would be alright. Can you imagine the pressure they must have felt? In attempting to fulfill the enormous psychological needs vested in them by others, they caved to their basest desires and lost sight of themselves. 

So many of us fulfill outsized psychological roles in the lives of others- particularly those in the so-called “Sandwich generation,” who are caring both for parents and for children. Indeed, it is not just within the family or the friendship unit that this is found; it falls along gender lines as well. Last month in the Atlantic, Peggy Orenstein published a heartbreaking article called “The Miseducation Of The American Boy,” in which she described the price men pay for a culture that assigns certain roles and stereotypes to them, that shames the need for affection and displays of emotion,  and that greets emotional or romantic vulnerability with scorn. One such price is that boys often feel they cannot confide in any men in their lives- not their peers, and in many cases, especially not their fathers. The heavy psychological lifting is therefore assigned to women. As she writes:

Girlfriends, mothers, and in some cases sisters were the most common confidants of the boys I met. While it’s wonderful to know they have someone to talk to—and I’m sure mothers, in particular, savor the role—teaching boys that women are responsible for emotional labor, for processing men’s emotional lives in ways that would be emasculating for them to do themselves, comes at a price for both sexes. Among other things, that dependence can leave men unable to identify or express their own emotions, and ill-equipped to form caring, lasting adult relationships.

When attempting to fulfill important roles in the lives of others, whether as caregivers, spouses or friends, Moshe’s concern is a real one. It can be easy to lose sight of our dreams and values, to take on roles that are inauthentic and to forget who we are. Remember that God does not necessarily ask us to be charismatic, talented  figures; He entrusts us with our life’s mission because of who we can be, not what we can do. A life well lived makes room for others to occupy intimate spaces within it, but even as we make room for others in our lives, our authentic voice should always be heard. 

Finding Lavan in All the Wrong Places

Prepared in partnership with Rabbi Shaanan Gelman

“Great place for basic kosher food and a nice little sandwich bar.”

“Run by nice people.”

These are some of the online reviews for Jersey City Kosher, the small shop founded three years ago to service the growing Chassidish community in Jersey City. For the past five years, families priced out of the chassidic enclaves of Boro Park and Williamsburg have begun to move to suburban New Jersey and Rockland County, in an attempt to establish themselves in more spacious quarters. The Greenville neighborhood of Jersey City featured older but roomy houses that fetched a price half that of an apartment in Brooklyn, and 100 or so families so far moved there, setting up a shul, a Yeshiva and a kosher store to service their needs. Relations with the neighbors were, by and large, positive even as tensions over gentrification, and aggressive home purchasing tactics, hovered in the background. The nice people who ran the store were Moishe and Leah Mindel Ferencz, among the pioneers of the Jersey City community. By all accounts, the couple were deeply kind, decent people who treated their employees and neighbors with generosity and respect. Leah Mindel Ferencz was one of those killed in the attack on Jersey City Kosher on Tuesday, along with her cousin Moishe Deutsch, her employee Miguel Douglas Rodriguez and Officer Joseph Seals, each one lamented as an extraordinary individual who was dedicated to his or her family and community. In what has become a depressingly and frighteningly regular occurrence, Jews have been killed once again for the crime of being Jewish.  and we find ourselves asking, once again: Where do we go from here? What should the response be for a Jew who is constantly under attack?

We have one such example at the very beginning of the week’s Parsha. In preparation for his fateful reunion with his twin brother Esav, Yaakov sends messengers- actual angels, according to some interpreters- to relay a message to him. 

וַיְצַ֤ו אֹתָם֙ לֵאמֹ֔ר כֹּ֣ה תֹאמְר֔וּן לַֽאדֹנִ֖י לְעֵשָׂ֑ו כֹּ֤ה אָמַר֙ עַבְדְּךָ֣ יַעֲקֹ֔ב עִם־לָבָ֣ן גַּ֔רְתִּי וָאֵחַ֖ר עַד־עָֽתָּה׃

“Thus shall you say, ‘To my lord Esau, thus says your servant Jacob: I stayed with Laban and remained until now;  This seems like a pretty straightforward message – Yaakov wants Esav to know what he has been up to recently, where he has been living, why it took so long to get to this place. 

But Rashi cites an interesting and somewhat bizarre midrash on the words “עם לבן גרתי”:

עם לבן גרתי, ותרי”ג מצוות שמרתי

I have been living with Lavan, and I have observed the 613 commandments this entire time. This rhyming midrash is based upon the fact that the word גרתי is an anagram of the letters תרי”ג, whose numeric equivalent is 613.  This is a cute example of wordplay but it is difficult to understand what would motivate Yaakov to send such a message. Leaving aside the obvious and well documented question of how Yaakov could possibly have observed all 613 commandments, or how he could do so while being married to sisters, why would Esav care that Yaakov remained steadfastly observant? Imagine the hatred Esav is harboring in his heart over the stolen blessings, the years of neglect and enmity piling up in a sibling relationship that turned toxic. Why would he be pacified with the knowledge that Yaakov sent away a mother bird before taking the chicks, or that he constructed a parapet around his roof, that he left a corner of his field unharvested for the benefit of the poor, and that he scrupulously avoided negative speech? Why would Esav care, and why would this knowledge prevent him from seeking vengeance?  

I’d like to suggest that Yaakov’s message is not conciliatory; he is not telling Esav about his frumkeit because he believes Esav will care. He is telling him about the Taryag mitzvos because he needs to hear himself say those words- that he is unabashedly proud about who he is and the kind of life he lives, and that he knows it’s the only way to counter those who seek our destruction. Esav may attempt to throw stones, to shoot up grocery stores, to threaten our physical safety, but he will never win so long as the Jews are still keeping the 613 commandments. 

When we are confronted with anti-Semitism- and we are, increasingly so; the FBI reports that 57.8% of all religiously motivated hate crimes in the US have been against Jews in 2019- there are two ways we typically respond. The first is to downplay the extent of the anti-Semitism, often due to political affiliation or a vested interest in doing so. Just over two weeks ago, we took a tour of historical Jewish Paris, from its beginnings to present day. As we stood on a street corner in the Marais listening to our guide, a young  man walked by with a kippah on his head. Our tour guide, Benjamin, correctly surmised that we must think that man is insane. Who walks around in Paris with a Kippah? He assured us that in fact, it is perfectly safe to do so, and that reports of anti semitic attacks in Paris, and sweeping French Jewish migration, have been vastly overblown. The truth, he said- that there are very few attacks annually, that the ones that do happen are wildly overhyped and that in the heavily Jewish neighborhoods in Paris, Jews and Moslems get along extremely well- does not sell. Now, of course, I don’t live there and can’t say for certain whether he is correct or not. I was only there as a tourist, and I saw plenty of Parisians with kippot packing various restaurants. But I do know about the attacks on Jewish cemeteries in France that happened just in the past week or two, I know how much French I heard on the street in Israel and of course, the memory of the massacre at Hyper Kosher- a store very similar to Jersey City Kosher- remains vivid in all our minds. When we heard about the shootout in Jersey City, we were quick to cling to the initial reports that indicated that this had nothing to do with Jews, and that the kosher store was in the wrong place at the wrong time. How desperately did we hope that this was right, and not another “Charlie Hebdo?” How wrong we were! The mayor of Jersey City, Steven Fulop, expressed his belief in a twitter post yesterday that the actual targets of David Anderson and Francine Graham were the children in the yeshiva next door; while he could not say for certain that was the case, he is sure that without the bravery and quick response of the police the situation would have been exponentially more horrifying. And once we knew that the store was targeted, how many of us held secret hopes that the identity of the perpetrator conformed to a certain preconceived image of who are today’s anti-Semites? But that’s the point- we don’t know who today’s anti Semites are because they could be anyone. 

The second impulse is to downplay our Judaism in the face of the threat it represents. Footage that went viral showed residents of Jersey City watching the antisemitic attack in their city; some were quoted blaming Jews for the attack while others were glad that Jews were being murdered. This is the safest play of all; after all, if I am targeted because of my religion, the prudent thing to do is mask it.  Yaakov does the opposite; instead of wearing a baseball hat or going bareheaded on the plane and going to sleep, he puts on tefillin as soon as it reaches cruising altitude! 

Here is the frightening reality. The Sifrei (Bemidbar 69) comments on a verse in this week’s Parsha:

R. Shimon b. Yochai says: It is a known halachah that Esav hates Jacob.

Our sages, when they said this, they did not mean that this is a rational reaction; instead, they were cautioning us that no political ideology and no religious group represents a safe harbor for Jews- not liberals and not conservatives, not moderate Moslems and not Evangelical Christians. There is no group that won’t turn against us given the right conditions, even if now they profess brotherhood. And while it is important to communicate with Esav, and to foster good relations with our neighbors, we mustn’t allow ourselves to be lulled into a false sense of security that we can consistently rely on anyone’s support or friendship. So what can we rely upon? There is only one guarantee that preserves our identity as Yaakov’s children. It is the strict observance of mitzvos.

Maybe the alarming increase in anti-Semitic event worldwide is the “knock” that Rav Soloveitchik described in Kol Dodi Dofek, the knock that tells us its time to pack our bags and make aliyah. Many will say that I’m delusional in prefacing that sentence with the word “maybe,” and they’re probably correct. The Jewish future is not here in galus; it is in the land of Israel. Notwithstanding that larger goal, when we consider what must be done to preserve Judaism wherever we are, to ensure its continuity, we often think about religious ideologies. Where is the future of Judaism? Is it in liberal movements of Judaism or Chareidi expressions, neo-chassidus, post denominational or Modern Orthodoxy?  I’m sure that everyone in this room has a different conception as to where our ideological future lies, quite aside from our geographical future.  But what we cannot forget is that the real future of Judaism rests in the pure observance of mitzvos, and the strict adherence to halacha- not in whatever external expression happens to feel right to a select group. 

You may have heard of a woman named Bracha “Beatie” Deutsch; she is making the headlines as of late, as a world class marathon runner. She is an olah who began running to stay in shape as a mother of five.  She never ran a race in her life, but within three years of training, she was already competing in and winning international marathons. Most remarkably, she has accomplished this as a deeply observant woman who identifies with the chareidi community, running races in a long sleeved top, a head scarf and a skirt that extends below her knees.  She was quoted in Runner’s World magazine as saying: 

“I’m proud that I can still pursue my dreams without sacrificing my values.”

Well, those values are now being put to test. Her dream of representing Israel at the 2020 Tokyo Olympics seemed like a foregone conclusion, until she discovered something unsettling, which prompted the following post:

I felt like I was punched in the stomach this morning… but the truth is I’m more than OK. I wasn’t sure if I should share the news with all of you right now, but I’ve brought you along on my journey this far. Today I found out that the Olympic marathon date has been switched to Shabbos…
I may not make it the Olympics… I may not make the standard or I may not be able to run a race that is on Shabbat But one thing I do know is that I will continue to proudly represent what it means to be an Orthodox Jewish woman and professional runner for Israel.

This is what Yaakov meant- 

עם לבן גרתי….ותרי”ג מצוות שמרתי

And it is the secret of his, and our longevity. Wherever I go, Yaakov says, I will not pull shtick and will never compromise on my identity as a shomer Torah Umitzvot, a identity and a life for which I am ready and willing to sacrifice. 

Tell your kids tonight, right after havdalah to take down the posters of Dirk Nowitzki, Luka Doncic and Serena Williams-and to put up a picture of Beatie Deutsch instead (though she might be appalled). She is the role model of what will sustain us in these dark times. May we never hear such tragic news again, but in the face of darkness, may we now and always reaffirm our connection to a Torah life.  

Inspiration and Introspection from Israel

 Vayeitzei 5780

As you know, on the weekend of January 10-11, we have the privilege of hosting Sivan Rahav Meir and Yedidia Meir as our scholars in residence. Many Americans don’t know who Sivan and Yedidya are, but in Israel, they are celebrities, journalists who have covered or broken some of the most significant news stories in the history of the State. In 2017, Sivan was chosen as the most influential female personality in Israel.  She is also an accomplished teacher who uses her fame and influence to spread Torah around the world. Her weekly Torah class takes place at Heichal Shlomo in Jerusalem and is viewed worldwide, transcribed and translated weekly into five languages at least. This year, the Meirs are on shlichut in the United States from World Mizrachi to learn about communities in the diaspora, and we are blessed that Dallas is one of them. There will be numerous events featuring her throughout the weekend, and you shouldn’t miss any of them. I am not telling you this merely to generate interest, though of course I am certainly telling you this to generate interest. Rather, I’ve been reflecting on two pieces of Torah she shared this week, after a horrific tragedy in Israel.

In the early hours of Sunday morning, Rabbi Ephraim and Tzipi Rimel were driving toward their yishuv, Neveh Tzuf, when they were rear ended by another driver who was speeding. Tzipi and their three week old daughter Noam Rachel were killed, while Rav Ephraim and their oldest son, Itai (12), are in critical condition and fighting for their lives. There was no terrorism alleged; it was just another horrific car accident, the kind that happen all too regularly in Israel due to the aggressive Israeli driving mentality, usually unreported because there is no external enemy to blame. Tzipi was a beloved educator and youth leader who was an invaluable presence in her yishuv, and her influence extended far beyond the borders of Israel. A few years ago, the Rimel family spent several years on Shlichut in the Torah MiTzion Kollel in Chicago, where she taught at the Ida Crown Jewish Academy. Even after they returned to Israel, they would host their former students from Chicago in their Israeli home.  It is hard to describe the degree to which this event shook the State of Israel, and the community of Chicago. My colleagues there tell me this is causing a deep theological crisis for many. Just hours before, the Rimel family were enjoying a celebratory Shabbos meal as a family, Tzipi no doubt cuddling with her newborn whose entire life lay ahead of her, everyone singing zemirot and sharing words of Torah around their Shabbos table.  Struggling to make sense of it, Sivan Rahav Meir invoked the imagery of our forefather Yaakov, on the road from Beersheva as he fled his brother Esav’s murderous designs. As he faces the uncertainty inherent in his journey, he makes God a promise:

וַיִּדַּ֥ר יַעֲקֹ֖ב נֶ֣דֶר לֵאמֹ֑ר אִם־יִהְיֶ֨ה אֱלֹקים עִמָּדִ֗י וּשְׁמָרַ֙נִי֙ בַּדֶּ֤רֶךְ הַזֶּה֙ אֲשֶׁ֣ר אָנֹכִ֣י הוֹלֵ֔ךְ וְנָֽתַן־לִ֥י לֶ֛חֶם לֶאֱכֹ֖ל וּבֶ֥גֶד לִלְבֹּֽשׁ׃

Jacob then made a vow, saying, “If God remains with me, if He protects me on this journey that I am making, and gives me bread to eat and clothing to wear,

וְשַׁבְתִּ֥י בְשָׁל֖וֹם אֶל־בֵּ֣ית אָבִ֑י וְהָיָ֧ה ה לִ֖י לֵאלֹקים׃

and if I return safe to my father’s house—the LORD shall be my God.

This wish of Yaakov’s is a simple one- that, in embarking on the journey of his life, he should return home, spiritually and physically intact regardless of the obstacles and adversities he might encounter. But if you think about it, this verse is perplexing. Why is Yaakov making a vow to God? God had just promised him everything he was asking for! 

In reflecting on this text, I came across a comment by Rav Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, in his Torah commentary “Kedushas Levi.” He explains that Yaakov’s request must have been for something that God had not initially promised. God had promised that He would watch over Yaakov whilst he was on his journey, but said nothing about what would happen upon his return. Yaakov, in response, was asking for divine assistance in the short and long term. As he commenced his journey, he required divine help to complete it safely. But even after he returned to his homeland and seemingly completed his mission, he realized that the hard work was only just beginning. As he began to start his family and establish his name, he needed a special measure of divine guidance. Indeed, the theme of family is addressed extensively throughout the rest of the Parsha. Yaakov meets Rachel, he builds a family with the birth of his sons, he and Rachel contend with fertility challenges, and he attempts to raise the people who were the building blocks of the Jewish nation in an environment whose values are inimical to his own.  

Commenting on Yaakov’s request for divine assistance along the road, and its juxtaposition with building his family, Sivan Rahav Meir said, 

“Many people heard this tragic news, stopped for a moment, and thought about these two fundamental things: to return home safely and to truly appreciate our families.”

Just a few days after sharing this reflection, Sivan shared another, on the same text. Yaakov’s vow to God contains a request that seems redundant, as he asks for “bread to eat and clothing to wear.” What other purpose would bread and clothing serve?  She quoted a simple yet profound idea from a young Chareidi mother of three named Chani Weinrot, who passed away in 2017 at the age of 34. In the final years of her life- which extended seven and a half more years than her doctors gave her- she dedicated herself to inspiring people, particularly those experiencing illness, to live meaningful and purposeful lives. In her book Shabbat Shalom Chani,  she alluded to her own experience in explaining that indeed, Yaakov’s request contains not one superfluous word. A person can have a thousand outfits in her closet, but cannot wear any as she is confined to a hospital gown. A person can have access to the finest foods, but cannot enjoy any of them on account of his ailments, allergies and adverse effects.  Our life itself, the people in it and our ability to enjoy it are so regularly taken for granted, but they require so much siyata dishamaya.

I’ve been thinking about this so much over the past week. While any of us, anywhere, can go at any time, the realization that life can end or change immediately and irrevocably seems more pronounced in Israel. No doubt this is because of its location in a volatile neighborhood, and the peril our young soldiers face in the course of their military service. There is a song by the singer Yaakov Shwekey that has practically become an anthem in Israel, and in American simchas as well, based on the verses in Kohelet (3:1). Minus repetitions, the words are:

לכל זמן ועת, עת לאהוב, עת לשנוא עת מלחמה, עת שלום..

אבל הלילה הזה כולנו בשמחה עת רקוד עוד ועוד

There is a time for everything- to love, to hate, to make war, to make peace, but tonight, we are all rejoicing, it’s the time to dance more and more. 

I think this song is so popular because it speaks to an attitude so many, especially Israelis, evince when attending a Simcha. In each of our lives, we are faced with plenty of reasons  for sadness, sources of stress, and triggers of anger. But at a wedding, right now, all we can do is be happy. I did not attend the funeral for Tzippi and Noam Rimel, but I know several people who did, and I was still thinking about it just hours afterward as we arrived at the wedding of Rosie Bernstein and Avi Greenbaum in Modi’in. Right after the Chuppah, I turned to Jessica in tears  and said, “I can’t stop thinking about Tzippi and Noam.” Jessica said to me, as she often does- “Get a grip! You’re at a wedding and you’re not here to be miserable.” She was right, of course. Thank God, I was able to pivot quickly, because we were seated at one massive table with numerous current and former Dallasites whom it was delightful to see again. Aside from the adults, though, it was so special to reconnect at the wedding with our kids who are studying in Israel for a gap year, with our college students, our Bnot Sherut from three different years, and our young people who made aliyah and are living their best lives in Israel. Rosie and Avi have many friends from different circles- Dallas and Detroit, Camp Stone, Yeshivat Orayta and Migdal Oz, Sherut Leumi and the IDF, but all of them had one thing in common: They partied hard. I don’t mean that they partied hard in a hedonistic or irresponsible way (at least that I know about); I mean that there was an unmatched intensity of celebration.  Josh and Jordana anticipated this when they arranged for two buses to return from the wedding- one at midnight, and one at 3 AM! I  joke sometimes about ways I can tell I’m getting old; at this wedding, I discovered another one. It was not that long ago that I attended weddings and danced in the  friends’ circle. Now, I attend weddings and dance in the fathers’ circle! And I don’t have to tell you which bus we rode back to Jerusalem… Now, it could be that the wedding was so intensely joyous because Rosie and Avi are among the first of their friends to marry, and everyone is really young. But I think it was also that sense you get in an Israeli simcha, where the participants are aware of life’s tenuousness and feel that every moment of joy must be maximized, every happy occasion enjoyed to its utmost.

This is the inspiration I derived, that spurred quite a bit of introspection during and after our trip. Thank God, we were blessed to return safely to our children, who somehow managed without us thanks to the loving care of wonderful family. Yaakov’s request for divine assistance teaches us to take nothing for granted- not safety in  a simple car ride, not the blessings of family that begin at a wedding, and certainly not the ability to enjoy the lives we’ve been granted. Let us celebrate life with passion and urgency, and may God continue to grant us divine assistance to enjoy it to its utmost. 

A Successful Sukkah

Sukkos Day II, 5780

 

We have now been in Dallas, thank God, for four years, yet people still ask me on occasion what I have found to be the biggest adjustment in our relocation. Usually, they want to know my perspectives on Dallas Jewry and how different it is from the communities on Long Island whence we came. When I give the real answer, most people are taken aback, so here it is: The real challenge I’ve experienced, the really difficult adjustment, has been the weather. I’m not referring to the dragon’s nostrils that is called Summer in Dallas. No- for me, the most significant adjustment has been the weather on Sukkos. Permit me to read you the forecast for Rochester, New York for today:

Partly cloudy, High 55, Low 47.

This is rather warm for a late Sukkos Rochester. My childhood memories involve the crimson and gold hues of glorious fall foliage, crispy apples and down coats in the Sukkah, seeing our breath and  eating hot stuffed cabbage. In fact, there were years in Rochester when it snowed!

Here is the weather forecast for Dallas:

Scattered showers, High 82, Low 63. 

And that’s for a cold front! I haven’t experienced weather even remotely like this, lehavdil,  since I had the privilege of spending Sukkos in Israel for two years when I was in Yeshiva. Most years here in Dallas, the weather has been in the mid to high 90s, with 50% humidity to boot. For reference, 50% humidity is the level maintained in Hot Yoga studios. And for some inexplicable reason, there are still fall foliage decorations being sold in Dallas, and pumpkin spice products available ad nauseum! Why do we persist in the mass delusion that there is a season called fall in this city?

In one part of the country, sitting in the Sukkah requires down coats and hot food. In another, it requires cool beverages and a fan or air conditioner. It is this discrepancy between the definitions of Sukkah discomfort that remains one of the biggest adjustments for me.

One of the great Chassidic masters, Rav Tzadok HaKohen Rabinowitz (1823-1900) shares a remarkable idea in his work Pri Tzaddik, in an essay on the holiday of Sukkos. Quoting the Pesikta and the yehi ratzon prayer we recite when sitting in the Sukkah, Rav Tzadok says that spending time outside in the temporary dwelling that is our Sukkah, exposed to the elements away from the creature comforts of our home, is meant to simulate the experience of exile. For those whose deeds last year necessitated a decree of exile for this one, the time we spend in the Sukkah should suffice.

 

Rav Tzadok points out that there is no way this can possibly work. Exile is supposed to evoke pain and separation. Albert Camus put it poignantly in “The Plague.”:

They came to know the incorrigible sorrow of all prisoners and exiles, which is to live in company with a memory that serves no purpose.

But if you look at the laws of the Sukkah, pain and discomfort is a reason to exempt a person from spending time in the Sukkah! Whether it is on account of blistering heat or bitter cold, sickness or suffering, our sages stated clearly- מצטער פטור מן הסוכה, one who experiences difficulty is exempt from the Sukkah. But if the Sukkah is meant to atone for sins requiring exile, no one should be exempt! After all, illness and discomfort weren’t deterrents from committing the sin that necessitated the punishment!

Rav Tzadok explains that the exile, the galus of the Sukkah is designed to simulate a very specific exile- the Baylonian exile. It was in the Baylonian exile that the transmission of Torah from teacher to student flourished, until the Rabbis committed it to writing to preserve it for posterity. It was in the Babylonian exile that the texts, concepts and debates that still represent the basis of Jewish law were formulated. It was in the Baylonian exile that many of the practices designed to strengthen observance were enacted by the Anshei Knesset HaGedolah, the men of the great assembly. It was in the Babylonian exile that Yehoshua Ben Gamla developed a  comprehensive system of Jewish education, so no child would be denied his Jewish heritage. And it was in the Babylonian exile that the first institutions of higher Jewish learning were developed- the yeshivot of Sura, Pumpedita and Nahardea. Indeed, this is the story of Jewish exile in general. Throughout our history of bitter persecution and relentless wandering, our exile has produced voluminous Torah scholarship from dozens of countries and thousands of communities across the globe, and Jewish movements that have changed the trajectory of Jewish history for the better. Our literary output has proven a rich vein of cultural gold, and our scientific contributions have changed the world. This is the kind of exile we are supposed to replicate through sitting in the Sukkah- a productive exile, tragic in origin yet glorious in outcome. Someone who is mitzta’er, who is afflicted, will only see the negative in the Sukkah and will look askance at its inhabitants as backward and irredeemable, failing to realize the growth potential a sojourn in the Sukkah carries. This is why the Mishnah Berurah writes that you should take whatever steps you can to make your Sukkah stay a comfortable one- whether putting in a fan or air conditioner or, as he was describing in Poland, wearing warm clothing. Mitzta’er– and the attitude it inheres- is something to be avoided as much as possible! Such people are exempt from the Sukkah, because they are not welcome there. One of the central assumptions in many streams of Zionist thought is known as Shlilat HaGalut, or negation of the diaspora. This school of thought has been used to deny the possibility of a rich Jewish life in the diaspora, and the value of the diaspora life that already took place. Early Zionist intellectuals like Yosef Haim Brenner and Micha Yosef Berdyczewski were its most vociferous proponents, and today, the mantle has been assumed by Israeli author A.B. Yehoshua.  Brenner and Berdyczewski portrayed Disapora Jews in the Pale of Settlement as poor and panicky, defeated and deferential, slovenly and stupid, whose accomplishments were marginal and unworthy of celebration. There is a pejorative expression in modern Hebrew called “תרבות גלותית”, a diaspora culture or mindset, in which a personor a community thinks like a meek, servile and generally foreign Jew.  The only way someone can think this way about the story of diaspora Jewry is if they, like so many of us, adopt a lachrymose approach to Jewish history. In this conception, we focus on the hardships and peregrinations we have had to endure, and not on the remarkable opportunities that hardship and exile created. After the attack on the shul in Halle on Yom Kippur, someone expressed to me their dismay that there are Jews living in Germany. After all, it’s a hell hole for Jews, isn’t it? Let’s leave aside the stunning arrogance inherent in writing off a community of 100,000+ Jews simply because we don’t approve of where they live. And let us brush past the troubling implication that Jews who live in places we deem dangerous are the architects of their own misfortune. This kind of talk betrays a shocking ignorance of Jewish history. Long before Germany was the epicenter of evil in the world, there was nearly a millennium of glorious Jewish life there. Much of our Ashkenazic liturgical and halachic practice originates from the works of the Rishonim who lived in the Rhineland. There were great Rabbis and halachic authorities who led Jewish communities throughout that time. The school of Torah im Derech Eretz originated in the writings and the community of Rav Samson Raphael Hirsch, and many secular Jewish scientists and intellectuals revolutionized the world on German soil.  Is that something to be ignored because things went so indescribably bad later on?

Of course, a paean to the positives of the diaspora is not in any way meant to oppose aliyah, God forbid, which every Jew should seriously consider, certainly now that it is so much easier, and which affords us unique and essential Jewish opportunities we simply don’t have in the Diaspora. But seeing the blessing in our exile, and focusing on our historic triumphs in it, is essential if we wish to develop an accurate and balanced view of our collective Jewish story, and our individual story as well. It is easy to adopt a depressing approach to our lives, in which we dwell on the difficulties we are suffering or the challenges we have endured in the past. Rav Tzadok teaches us that it is easier, better and healthier to look positively upon our lives, searching for growth opportunities amidst adversity, and reflecting on the way we’ve been strengthened by past challenges. As we dwell within the sukkah, let us do so with a spirit of joy and understanding, so that the Sukkah will dwell within us, too.

 

Earth Day 5780

Israel is not just the startup nation, home to titans of technology and the citing edge of innovation; it is tragically and inexplicably the home of the world’s cheapest, flimsiest  plasticware, items whose quality is so embarrassingly rock bottom you wouldn’t find them in an American dollar store. Given the inferior quality of Israeli disposables, it’s no surprise that Israel is second in the world in consumption of single-use plasticware, known in Israel as חד פעמי. Every cup requires a reinforcement and every meal necessitates several iterations of the same utensil, because the first two or three snapped or melted.   Just before Rosh Hashanah, a group of illustrious Israeli Rabbis signed a memorandum in which they begged the Israeli public to reduce their reliance on plasticware. You may have heard of some of the signatories to the letter: Rabbi Shlomo Aviner, head of Jerusalem’s Ateret Yerushalim Yeshiva; Rabbi Yuval Cherlow, director of the Tzohar Center for Jewish Ethics at the Tzohar rabbinical organization and the Ofra settlement’s chief Rabbi Avi Gisser. As this issue has gained traction, other environmental issues have also taken root in Israel, including the establishment of the very first carpool lane ever in Israel. 

 

These stories emerge onto the scene precisely when our attention was drawn to a public outcry over environmental concerns.  Leading the charge was the now famous Swedish teen Greta Thunberg, a polarizing figure who, depending on your perspective, is either a modern day prophet or a stunningly unaware and privileged person who has no idea what actually happens in the real world.  

As Jews, the fact that Rabbis have recently issued an environmental declaration might raise our eyebrows. The Orthodox community has, historically, been silent, indifferent or even oppositional to environmental conversations. This reticence is understandable; often times, the spokespersons of environmentalism speak with a fervor matched by the most zealous religious practitioners- yet they are often not conventionally religious themselves. Some might even say that environmentalism has become a religion of its own, in which those who follow its constructs are saintly, and those who ignore them are profligate sinners. This has served as a turnoff to many in our community. However, the imperfect, annoying or sanctimonious messengers should not render the message invalid. I’m not here to quote any of the abundant scientific research that has emerged over the last several decades, indicating that we wrought damage to the planet with severe, immediate and far reaching consequences. I am certainly not here to quote the pundits on all sides, either hyping up or downplaying the issue. What I am here for is to teach Torah and expound upon the messages of the glorious holiday of Sukkos. 

 

The talmud tells us that the Arba minim, the four species must taken דרך גידולן , in accordance with their manner of growth. We are doing our utmost to honor and preserve nature as it is in its initial form. Interestingly, the Bnei Yisaschar points out that each of these species share something in common: they can grow naturally, and unabated, without the interference of people. 

Another connection between Sukkos and nature is the halacha that the schach that covers your Sukkah must be harvested from a natural source; wooden slats, bamboo, pine boughs- all these are suitable. However,  the moment it is turned into a kli, a vessel fashioned by man, it is no longer appropriate for use.The technical reason is that a vessel can contract ritual impurity, but it is also because the Sukkah is no longer in pristine form, as God intended it. Paradise has been spoiled. 

 

Throughout most of the year, man is challenged to be productive, to generate something of substance from very little; to turn a canvas into a work of art, to turn steel and wood into a house, and to use brains and ingenuity to generate revenue and income. The challenge with this kind of life is that we become increasingly distant from nature, and forgetful of the gift that was handed to us. For eight days, however, we are tasked with a different kind of productivity- maintaining God’s world in its most unspoiled form. Consider for a moment the hoops we jump through to preserve the aravos each year. Ask three Jews, and you will get four opinions on the best way to store your Aravos each night: wrap in a wet cloth, wrap it in aluminum foil or not, in the fridge or not, or do nothing at all. We sense that there is some kind of preservation we need to perform, and that there are steps we need to take, but all we know is that we have a simple mandate: preserve as best we can

. 

The Medrash relates a conversation between God and Adam. He took him by the arm and showed him each tree, proclaiming- “all of this beauty was created for your benefit! Pay attention and don’t destroy my world, for if you do, there is no one to repair it after you.”

קהלת רבה (וילנא) פרשה ז

בשעה שברא הקב”ה את אדם הראשון נטלו והחזירו על כל אילני גן עדן ואמר לו ראה מעשי כמה נאים ומשובחין הן וכל מה שבראתי בשבילך בראתי, תן דעתך שלא תקלקל ותחריב את עולמי, שאם קלקלת אין מי שיתקן אחריך

This means that man may use nature only in such a way as to enhance it, not put it at risk; to appreciate it as it is, and not try to wrestle it under our control. We must use it, but only for what need, and not in a way that overburdens the planet. Nature is not a destination, it’s not a resource exclusively for our needs and pleasures. It is a place where we meet God; picture Him holding you by the hand and asking you “please don’t destroy my world.” 

 

So if we are stewards of this planet, what obligation is placed upon us? None of us can save the planet single-handedly, but we must do our own share. Perhaps that means we need to rethink our obsession with meat; I am certainly among the carnivores, and I know I’m not prepared to remove meat from my diet completely. The very first wedding I ever officiated was for two vegans. The smorg was tofu in every possible ethnic variation. I have nothing against tofu, per se (particularly if other people are eating it) but after the wedding, I went to the closest kosher swarm place. I may have conveyed some distinctly un-rabbinic sentiments when I discovered it was closed… But what if we removed meat from our diet one day a week? You don’t even have to do without the delicious taste- there is at least one kosher restaurant in our community that serves The Impossible Burger.  If we are intellectually honest, we should realize that reducing our consumption of meat alleviates strain on limited planetary resources. As Rav Moshe Cordovero, in his classic Kabbalistic work Tomer Devorah stated:

Because of this, a person should not denigrate any creatures, for they were all created with intelligence. Therefore, a person should not uproot any growing items with no purpose, and should not kill any living thing for no reason, and when he does have to kill an animal, he should do so with a knife that has been properly checked so as to minimize pain. 

Reb Aryeh Levine (1885-1969), known as the ‘Tzaddik of Jerusalem,’ recorded the following incident in his memoirs:

I recall the early days, after 1905, when God granted me the privilege to ascend to the Holy Land; and I arrived at Jaffa. There I first merited meeting our great master, Rabbi Abraham Isaac Kook (of blessed memory), who greeted me with good cheer, as was his sacred custom to receive all people.

 

We chatted together on various Torah topics. After an early Minchah (the afternoon prayer-service), he went out, as was his custom, to stroll a bit in the fields and collect his thoughts. I accompanied him.

During the walk, I plucked a twig or a flower. Our great master was taken aback when he saw this. He told me gently:

“Believe me — in all my days, I have been careful never to pluck a blade of grass or flower needlessly, when it had the ability to grow or blossom. You know the teaching of the Sages, that there is not a single blade of grass below, here on earth, which does not have a heavenly force above telling it, Grow!

“Every sprout and leaf of grass says something, conveys some meaning. Every stone whispers its inner message in its silence. Every creature utters its song [of praise for the Creator].”

Those words, spoken from a pure and holy heart, engraved themselves deeply on my heart. From then on, I began to feel a strong sense of compassion for all things.

Perhaps we can start thinking about the way we conduct ourselves at smachot and other public functions. There’s nothing wrong with using the same plate when you want to take seconds from the buffet; if we did that here, we wouldn’t just save money- we would reduce our imprint on God’s world. Not to mention following the recommendation of the Rabbis in Israel.  Perhaps we can look into reducing our reliance on disposable plasticware, switching to paper and biodegradables.  In addition to the environmental and financial benefits of conservation, there is another benefit to awareness of this mitzvah. What if, once a month, we went through our pantries in search of canned or dried goods we won’t use. Rather than just sitting there taking up space or worse, throwing them away, call up JFS and donate them. 

 

In 2008, a commercial aired showing two people sitting on a couch, on a beach in Virginia. A closer look revealed that they were the Rev. Al Sharpton and the Rev. Pat Robertson. It was a commercial for an initiative called wecansolveit.org, about climate change and preservation of the environment. These two men have nothing in common, their mutual feeling that the other one is insane, and for various manifestations of their problematic relationship with the Jewish community. But they sat together on that couch and talked about how concern for the environment is not a partisan issue, and is terribly important. No matter your feelings about these individuals, they had the right idea. The lesson of Sukkos is that concern for our world is not a Democratic or Republican value, it is not a liberal or conservative mandate, it is not just for liberal or “progressive” Jews- it is a Torah value.  

Today, on Sukkos, God’s voice beckons all of us to become one with nature once again. As we head toward finishing the Torah and Parshas Bereishis is on the horizon, we can understand that one of the tragic results of the banishment from Eden is the distance we feel from God’s creations, and from our responsibility for them. Let us learn the message of the Sukkah, and creation itself, and be worthy stewards of our world- לעבדה ולשמרה.

 

 

 

 

Fear Factor- Rosh Hashanah 5780

Prepared in partnership with Rabbi Shaanan Gelman.

 

Picture the scene: At noon on Shabbos, a bus stops on the corner of Churchill and Hughes. The bus discharges its passengers, each one armed with a cell phone snapping photos furiously of the latest  curiosity. You wonder at first, what is it that they are photographing? What can be so intriguing about this nondescript suburban street corner? And then it hits you – they are staring at us and photographing, because we are observant Jews.  “Look at them in their prayer shawls,” they exclaim. “How can they walk in this heat?” and “Look how many children these people have!” This sounds outlandish, even dystopian, but that’s only because it’s not happening here. But it is happening elsewhere, every day, several times a day. Tourists readily pay $55 to gawk and observe Chassidic Jewish life, partaking of a trendy and chic grand tour of New York City, called “The Contrast Tour.” On this whirlwind expedition, you will drink in the diversity of the City that Never Sleeps- from the graffiti laden walls of the South Bronx to the ethnic restaurants of Queens, concluding with a journey to Williamsburg, the redoubt of the Satmar Chassidim in Brooklyn. This may seem benign, but the tour guides on these tours have been overheard spreading awful stereotypes about the members of that community. And reducing a group to a tourist attraction at which to gawk and snap photos is not as benign as it seems. We all know that this human safari takes place on the backdrop of a terrifying reality, rapidly spreading around the country. A hateful sticker is posted on a telephone pole right here on our street in Dallas; two Chabad houses set on fire in Massachusetts, a shul incinerated in Minnesota, and  a firebomb discovered on the premises of a shul in Chicago. In this past year, dozens of Orthodox Jews have been attacked in the most brutal manner for no reason other than their visible religious identification- and police refuse to categorize these attacks as hate crimes. This is taking place not in Israel and not only in the capitals of Europe, where Jews know to hide who they are, but in the very neighborhoods that these tour buses so regularly visit- Boro Park, Crown Heights and Williamsburg. The Jewish map of martyrdom added fresh locations this year; mentions of Poland and Germany, Hebron and Sderot are no longer the only names that cause us to tremble. Now, the mere mention of Pittsburgh and Poway elicit the same reaction. 

 

This past year, the year 5779, may be best defined with one word: פחד- fear. Fear affects every aspect of Jewish communal life; shul budgets inflated by security concerns to entirely new departments established at Federations to address security needs, especially as relates to the rise in antisemitism. Not a soul within our community remains unscathed by this fear;  From innocent school children sitting through terrifying videos demonstrating active shooter scenarios; responsible communities devising emergency response plans for those events; community members turning against one another as they debate how best to address these hot button issues.  

 

This is on top of the traditional concerns which plague our thoughts this time of year – from health for ourselves and our loved ones, to parnassah, to safety in Israel. And yet, with all that on our minds, we are going to turn to God in a few minutes and beg of him ובכן תן פחדך- instill fear within us.   Does Avrohom Gopin of Crown Heights, who is recovering from a traumatic head injury when he was beaten with a rock, need to ask for more fear in his life? Is there a Jew anywhere who needs more fear? What we need instead is a little less fear, and in fact, the Talmud gives us a prescription for reducing anxiety associated with the Day of Judgement. 

 

The Sages of Talmudic times supplied us with three surefire indicators of what the coming year will look like (Kareitot 5a-b):

דכיפורי וניתלי בביתא דלא נשיב זיקא אי משיך נהוריה נידע דמסיק שתיה

 

Rav Ami says: One who desires to know if he will live through this current year or not should bring a lit candle during those ten days between Rosh HaShana and Yom Kippur and hang it in a house through which wind does not blow, and he should watch it carefully: If its light continues he shall know that he will live out his year.

 

So go home tonight/tomorrow night, light a candle, place it away from the wind- and see how long it lasts. The symbolism of the candle is self evident; the book of Proverbs describes the human soul as the candle of God. So why are we not doing this?  Why even bother changing the way we speak and what we do? If the candle remains lit, we have nothing to worry about. And if the candle blows out, we’ll have our work cut out for us on Yom Kippur!

 

Others feel, perhaps foolishly, that concern about about their mental and physical health or their longevity is of lesser consequence. Instead, they are deeply and understandably preoccupied with financial stability and success. There is a proverb of disputed origin that goes as follows:

 

אדם דואג על איבוד דמיו, ואינו דואג על איבוד ימיו

דמיו אינם עוזרים, ימיו אינם חוזרים

Man worries about losing his dollars, and not about losing his days;

His dollars will not help, and his days will not return.  

 

But as much as that statement rings true, financial concerns loom large today. How will I pay tuition for the coming year, and how will I meet our other routine expenses? How will I pay for an upcoming simcha- or, lehavdil, an unforeseen illness? If things have been going well financially, will that continue? Rest assured that the Talmud offers a test for this persistent  thought as well. 

 

ומאן דבעי נעביד עיסקי ובעי דנידע אי מצלח עיסקי אי לא נירבי תרנגולא אי שמין ושפר נידע דמצלח

 

And one who desires to conduct business and wants to know if his business will succeed or not, should raise a rooster. If the rooster gets fat and beautiful he shall know that the venture will succeed.

 

The symbolism of the fattened chicken is also clear; it represents prosperity. So the solution is simple: go home and buy a rooster. Join the ranks of the backyard suburban farmers! Don’t use the chicken for kapparos– in fact, skip kaparos altogether this year! Just fatten up the rooster and see if it becomes zaftig. No market volatility, no job insecurity, no need to argue with your spouse about purchases or major life decisions- we have the best financial litmus test of all. 

 

And lastly, when it comes to all of those terrible fears for our safety- from the harrassment to the beatings, from the shootings to the bombings, the Talmud offers us another solution: 

 

האי מאן דבעי ניפוק באורחא ובעי דנידע אי הדר לביתיה ניעול ניקום בביתא דבהתא אם חזי בבואה לבבואה דבבואה נידע דאתי לביתיה ולאו מילתא היא דילמא חלשא דעתיה ומתרע מזליה

 

One who wishes to leave on a journey and wants to know whether he will return to his home should enter a dark house. If he sees the reflection [bavua] of a reflection of his reflection he shall know that he will return and come to his home. 

 

Here, the shadow represents a person’s essence. If it is present, it means that he still is viable, that he still has an impact upon his world, hence an indication that he will return home safely.  So all you need to do is enter a room and turn off all the lights. If you can still see your silhouette, you are guaranteed a safe journey. No insurance necessary, no security, no tefillas haderech– just the flick of a switch. 

 

It all seems so easy. A life-hack, quite literally.  If we have an opportunity to predict the future, why wouldn’t we seize it? But then the Gemara does an about-face, and tells us that, on second thought, this is all a terrible idea. Judaism is not interested in quick fixes; rather, we are told to embrace our fears and live with uncertainty. ובכן תן פחדך- Lord, give me some fear!

 

If we are asking for fear, it must be a different kind. Not the fear that FDR described when he said

“the only thing we have to fear is…fear itself”…

But rather, a different kind of fear described by his wife Eleanor:

You gain strength, courage and confidence by every experience in which you really stop to look fear in the face. You are able to say to yourself, ‘I have lived through this horror. I can take the next thing that comes along.’ You must do the thing you think you cannot do.”

In other words, try your very best to do that which scares you. 

 

FDR exhorts us to live fearlessly; Eleanor Roosevelt empowers us to live with fear. 

Today’s mantra of seeking safe-spaces, avoiding triggers and micro-aggressions and meditation exercises designed to block out discomfort – these are all designed as avoidance strategies, to numb our senses and dodge that which is painful or frightening.   We are teaching an entire generation that it is healthy and desirable to steer clear of disappointment and heartache.   

Today we pray for fear not because we are a religion of masochists, but because we know that the best of us will emerge when we confront anxiety.  And this is why the Gemara does away with these simanim.  

The question we must ask ourselves on this most fateful day is simple:

When our lives hang in the balance, when we are confronted by all that which haunts us and causes us to lose sleep at night – Will we be safe and secure under the protective blanket of our shadow, watching our candle with great intent and counting the caloric intake of our rooster, or will we rise to live a true life? Will we choose to live a large life or a small one?  

Let this not be a year in which we are content with just being “safe.” Surely we are better than hunkering down and avoiding risk! 

As financier John Shedd pointed out:

“A ship in harbor is safe — but that is not what ships are built for.”

We too are built for more.

So if 5779 was the year in which Jews were inundated by fear, then let 5780, תש”פ become a year when we do something audacious which we previously feared.

Perhaps this is the year in which we initiate a reconciliation with a family member, even if fear of rejection or of admitting our own mistakes  keeps us from picking up the phone. 

Maybe this is the year in which we study Torah with our children.  Certainly, there is the fear that we don’t know enough, that they will be uninterested (or that we are) or that it will turn us into the kind of families that buses stop and photograph. Today, right now, think about a book, or a subject, or a tractate that you can begin in your home on a regular basis.

Maybe this is the year in which we change the way we view shul membership and communal involvement. I had an “Aha moment” when I read a comment left on my facebook wall on by someone named Danny Groner, with whom I’m friendly from my Jewish Center days on Manhattan’s Upper West Side. He described an attitude shift he undertook when he began to view his shul membership like a gym membership. Can you imagine a gym in which people pay significant sums annually and then show up for an hour a week, play around with a machine or two, go on the treadmill for a few minutes and then stand in the hallway and talk to their friends for the duration? Or they don’t go into the gym at all, and instead go directly for the cafe.  It is clear then when we join a gym, the more we put in in terms of attendance and effort, the more rewarding the experience will be for us- and the more we get out of the money we spend on it. Danny started going to weekday classes, Friday night davening, introduced himself to new people each week in shul and joined several committees. It changed his life- he expanded his circle of friends, and his circle of influence, because he was willing to put in the work to be counted, and counted on. Instead of asking, “What am I or my kids getting for my membership dollars,” why not ask, “Am I making the most of my membership dollars?” Our shul is our spiritual gym, and our investment is maximized when our efforts and attendance are as well.  attended the Beit Midrash night and initiated study partnerships? What if we came earlier to davening and stayed for more of it, or volunteered for committees or events? We need to adopt a more audacious attitude, one that encourages us to do that which scares us.

Many of you may recall when Racheli Frenkel, the noted Torah scholar and mother of Naftali hy”d, one of the three boys murdered in the summer of 2014 came to speak in Dallas a few years ago.  In a recent interview, she shared that an American Rabbi came to pay a shiva visit on behalf of his congregation. He mentioned that on the airplane, he and the flight attendant were talking, and the purpose of his visit came out. She was so impressed with this gesture that she told several people sitting nearby. The Rabbi’s seatmate was not observant, but he was powerfully moved and inspired by the Rabbi’s selflessness.  In turn, he too was motivated to take on an intrepid, audacious and uncomfortable commitment. Right there, on that plane, he announced that he planned on putting on Tefillin at the next possible opportunity. He added that it would be the first time he would do so since his bar mitzvah.

Across the aisle, a Satmar chassid  overheard the entire conversation. Mind you, Samar Chassidim- while paragons of cheesed in many ways- are not necessarily known for outreach to those who are not observant, and Tefillin campaigns are usually associated with Chabad. However, when he heard this, he said, “Please give me your address; I will have Tefillin delivered to your home.” When the Rabbi came to the shiva, he related this extraordinary chain of events, and told Mrs. Frenkel that the Hebrew name Naftali- which means triumph through struggle – is an anagram of the Hebrew word Tefillin. It had never occurred to her that this was the case. In her grief, she realized that in Naftali’s all too short life, he never missed a day of Tefillin. 

That’s the thing about Jewish courage, what the chassidic masters call azus dekedusha, holy courage – it is contagious, and spreads virtue in its wake.  Tenacity in the face of fear and apathy is what fuels the heart of the Jew.  Maybe our fear didn’t change the way we live our lives the past year, but this year, God, תן פחדך- give us opportunities to stare down and grow from our fears, and become the best people we can be. 

 

 

 

 

 

Thoughts on a significant birthday- Ki Tavo 5779

On Monday night, I came home after my class and found two envelopes on my bed. Both of them contained birthday cards- one from Jessica, the other from the kids. The card from the children had a picture of Spiderman on the front, saying “Dad- for heroes like you, with great power comes great responsibility. But with birthdays come presents and cake- so enjoy your day and have a great one!” It was such a lovely card, and it warmed my heart. The one from Jessica, on the other hand, was like a punch to the gut. On the front, it said: “They say life begins at 40.” On the inside, it said, “Well, then, what have you been doing until now? My God! Typical 40-year old nonsense.” What a scathing indictment! Just to pick one Rabbinic example, when Rav Moshe Isserles, the Rema, was my age in 1570, he had already written his supercommentary called Darchei Moshe on the Tur, and summarized it in the form of his super commentary on the Shulchan Aruch.   Lehavdil, when Bibi Netanyahu was my age, he hadn’t even conducted one failed election! e was just getting warmed up as Deputy Foreign Minister in the government of Yitzchak Shamir. When Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart was my age, he had composed 41 symphonies, 27 Piano Concertos, hundreds of pieces of chamber music and 21 operas; most importantly, when Mozart was my age, he’d been dead for five years! 

 

This Shabbos falls between my 40th secular birthday, which was on Monday, and my Hebrew birthday, which occurs on Wednesday (the date of Jessica’s secular birthday). I want to thank all of your for your calls, emails and facebook posts, some of which welcomed me to the fourth floor, reassuring me that the 40s are terrific. Starting in England of the early 20th century, the phrase “over the hill” has been used to describe reaching one’s fifth decade, when one has just passed his or her prime.  Since the back problems I experienced this summer, I’ve begun to feel that there is truth to this expression- if only it didn’t hurt to climb hills…For the past few days, I’ve been reflecting on this milestone, and in so doing, I realized that the number 40, in our tradition, is a decidedly mixed bag. Perhaps the most famous instance of the number 40 is the 40 day period Moshe spent, twice, when receiving the Torah. However, there are a few other instances of 40 that aren’t quite as…uplifting. Consider the evidence:

  1. The rain that created the flood in the days of Noach lasted forty days and nights (Genesis 7:12).

וַֽיְהִ֥י הַגֶּ֖שֶׁם עַל־הָאָ֑רֶץ אַרְבָּעִ֣ים י֔וֹם וְאַרְבָּעִ֖ים לָֽיְלָה׃

The rain fell on the earth forty days and forty nights.

  1. The period of embalming in Egypt, that preserved the body of Yaakov, also spanned 40 days.

וַיִּמְלְאוּ־לוֹ֙ אַרְבָּעִ֣ים י֔וֹם כִּ֛י כֵּ֥ן יִמְלְא֖וּ יְמֵ֣י הַחֲנֻטִ֑ים וַיִּבְכּ֥וּ אֹת֛וֹ מִצְרַ֖יִם שִׁבְעִ֥ים יֽוֹם׃

It required forty days, for such is the full period of embalming. The Egyptians bewailed him seventy days;

  1. 40 is the required amount of lashes administered by the court.

אַרְבָּעִ֥ים יַכֶּ֖נּוּ לֹ֣א יֹסִ֑יף פֶּן־יֹסִ֨יף לְהַכֹּת֤וֹ עַל־אֵ֙לֶּה֙ מַכָּ֣ה רַבָּ֔ה וְנִקְלָ֥ה אָחִ֖יךָ לְעֵינֶֽיךָ׃ (ס)

He may be given up to forty lashes, but not more, lest being flogged further, to excess, your brother be degraded before your eyes.

Later, our sages interpreted the words in this verse to reduce the number to 39 lashes. 

  1. Finally, King David talks about God’s view of the generation of the wilderness, those who were freed from slavery:

אַרְבָּ֘עִ֤ים שָׁנָ֨ה ׀ אָ֘ק֤וּט בְּד֗וֹר וָאֹמַ֗ר עַ֤ם תֹּעֵ֣י לֵבָ֣ב הֵ֑ם וְ֝הֵ֗ם לֹא־יָדְע֥וּ דְרָכָֽי׃

Forty years I was provoked by that generation; I thought, “They are a senseless people; they would not know My ways.”

So it is not at all clear whether forty is a “lucky number.” Fortunately, our sages provide us with the definitive answer in Pirkei Avos (5:21), in quoting Rav Yehuda ben Teima:

הוּא הָיָה אוֹמֵר, בֶּן חָמֵשׁ שָׁנִים לַמִּקְרָא, בֶּן עֶשֶׂר לַמִּשְׁנָה, בֶּן שְׁלשׁ עֶשְׂרֵה לַמִּצְוֹת, בֶּן חֲמֵשׁ עֶשְׂרֵה לַתַּלְמוּד, בֶּן שְׁמֹנֶה עֶשְׂרֵה לַחֻפָּה, בֶּן עֶשְׂרִים לִרְדֹּף, בֶּן שְׁלשִׁים לַכֹּחַ, בֶּן אַרְבָּעִים לַבִּינָה,

He used to say: At five years of age the study of Scripture; At ten the study of Mishnah; At thirteen subject to the commandments; At fifteen the study of Talmud; At eighteen the bridal canopy; At twenty for pursuit [of livelihood]; At thirty the peak of strength; At forty wisdom. 

Why is forty the age of wisdom? Believe it or not, the source is found at the very end of this week’s Torah portion. After 40 years wandering in the desert, Moshe tells the Jewish people (Devarim 29:3-4)-

וְלֹֽא־נָתַן֩ יְהוָ֨ה לָכֶ֥ם לֵב֙ לָדַ֔עַת וְעֵינַ֥יִם לִרְא֖וֹת וְאָזְנַ֣יִם לִשְׁמֹ֑עַ עַ֖ד הַיּ֥וֹם הַזֶּֽה׃

Yet to this day the LORD has not given you a mind to understand or eyes to see or ears to hear.

וָאוֹלֵ֥ךְ אֶתְכֶ֛ם אַרְבָּעִ֥ים שָׁנָ֖ה בַּמִּדְבָּ֑ר לֹֽא־בָל֤וּ שַׂלְמֹֽתֵיכֶם֙ מֵעֲלֵיכֶ֔ם וְנַֽעַלְךָ֥ לֹֽא־בָלְתָ֖ה מֵעַ֥ל רַגְלֶֽךָ׃

I led you through the wilderness forty years; the clothes on your back did not wear out, nor did the sandals on your feet;

 

Only on this day, after 40 years of wandering, did the Jewish people understand the purpose of their peregrinations, the challenges Moshe faced as their leader and the obstacles they were about to face as they entered into the promised land. Indeed, it is based on this that the sage Raba asserts that you must study with a teacher for 40 years before truly understanding them!

 

But these verses don’t really answer the question. What is it that happens magically upon reaching the age of 40, that confers wisdom upon those who do? Rabbi Yisrael Lifschitz, in his commentary Yachin on the Mishnah, writes that when a person reaches the age of 40, כבר נתבשל כח שכלו להבין דבר מתוך דבר- their intellects have become “ripe,” able to infer one thing from another. This  applies to intellectual pursuits, such as reading texts closely, understanding what they are and are not saying, and why. But it also applies in the emotional realm, especially in the way we interact with others. If a person follows the sequence of milestones outlined in the Mishnah, they will be married at 18 and well established as parents and even grandparents by the age of 40. It is through these life experiences that a person develops the understanding necessary to interact with others successfully. Since Daniel Goleman’s 1995 book with the same title, the concept and the terminology of Emotional Intelligence have become widely embraced.  The Dictionary of Psychology defines it as:

 

“… the ability of a person to recognize his or her emotions and those of others, discern between different feelings and label them appropriately, use emotional information to guide thinking and behavior, and manage and/or adjust emotions to adapt to environments or achieve one’s goal.”

 

“Using emotional information to guide thinking and behavior…manage and/or adjust emotions to adapt to environments…”- that is exactly what מבין דבר מתוך דבר is.  Employers are beginning to realize that EQ is a much more desirable attribute than IQ; EQ predicts how will you will get along with co-workers, how you will service your clients  and how you will care for your patients. It is  an attribute that can be learned and developed, while IQ is innate and static. Being able to understand one thing from another will determine your ability to understand the whole person you are speaking to. It is what allows us to give a word of encouragement to someone who needs it, even if they look like they are holding it together. It is how we know that certain topics of conversation are too sensitive for our interlocutors, and it is what enables us to deal with difficult people.  

When I served as Assistant Rabbi at The Jewish Center, we ran a service on a Sunday before Pesach where we kashered people’s dishes, kiddush cups and certain kinds of pots as well. A fellow showed up with three of his pots, and I told him that, for halachic reasons, I could not kasher them. He became highly agitated, and said, “But I have been kashering them every year!” I told him that he was welcome to kasher his pots at home if he wished, but that the Jewish Center halachic guidelines were that we could not kasher the pots he had supplied. With this, he lost it. “LISTEN, PIPSQUEAK! I’ve been kashering these pots for years, and I won’t have you telling me what I can and can’t do!” I became flustered, and asked him sternly to remove himself from the premises. He reached into his pocket and pulled out a check, one he had prepared for charity, and tore it in my face as he stomped out of the kitchen. I was so shocked by this incident that I relayed it to one of my Rabbinic mentors to get his take on what he would have done (I was also a little traumatized and needed to speak with someone…) In one sentence, he changed my perspective. “Can you imagine,” he asked, “what a holy terror his wife is?” Suddenly, it came clear to me. This man’s wife sends him out of the house with one measly assignment: to kasher three small pots. She probably  thinks he is generally incompetent, a disappointment and a failure, and misses no opportunity to remind him of how she feels. And he probably feels inferior anyway; all his fancy Upper West Side friends are going away for Pesach, and he isn’t, possibly for financial reasons. Now he has a chance to show his wife that he’s worth something, and I denied him even that opportunity!” If I were a little older, if I had the ability to read between the lines at that moment, I’d like to think my interaction with this person would have been a lot less traumatic for me, and while I might still have told him to leave, I might have viewed him a lot more  compassionately- even without changing my halachic ruling.  The Mishnah is telling us that at the time of life when we are most responsible for others, we need to emphasize the value of acquiring binah, of understanding one thing from another, that will make so many of our interpersonal interactions considerably less fraught and de-escalate conflict dramatically.  Does that mean everyone becomes less combative when they turn 40? Of course not! There are plenty of people age 40 and above who elevate belligerence to an artform. Do people  become uniquely sensitive and insightful when they go “over the hill”? Nonsense- there are plenty of people above 40 who possess the EQ of charcoal. But as I begin my fifth decade, and we begin a new year, I bless us all, especially myself, that we learn the lesson of the 40s. Let us work to develop our emotional quotient, so that this year is one of peace, harmony and understanding.   

 

Conducting Critical Conversations- Shofetim 5779

It was a busy Friday afternoon two weeks ago at the “Sharonim” mall in Hod HaSharon, Israel. A young man named Yisrael Hirsch was minding his own business and complete his pre-Shabbos shopping, when he claims a woman began harassing him verbally. It didn’t stop there; in a video that has since gone viral, Hirsch described what happened. 

“Something like this has never happened to me before. Apparently, because I am dressed as a Chareidi, someone permitted herself to nearly run me over with her vehicle and scream at me, ‘draft dodger, leave our country!’” 

The irony is that this alleged attacker picked on the wrong person! Yisrael Hirsch is one of the  growing numbers of Chareidim who enlist in the IDF annually. He served served a full tour of duty as a paratrooper and is now a commander in the elite Charuv Reconnaissance Unit, serving as an Army Rabbi. I can’t help but wonder whether the alleged assailant would have done the same thing to supermodel Bar Refaeli, one of the most famous and unapologetic of the Israeli draft dodgers. In an interview in 2007, Refaeli said, 

I’m not against the army and I really wanted to serve, but I do not regret that I did not enlist, because this decision has paid off big time…What does it matter, Uganda or Israel? For me, it does not matter. Why is it good to die for our country? Isn’t it better to live in New York? For what reason do children aged 18 need to sacrifice their lives? It makes no sense that people should die so that I can live in Israel.

While this cultural chasm is nothing new to us- even as we watch from the sidelines- it seems that the Jewish people have long contended with the issue of draft exemptions. Indeed, in this week’s parsha, the Torah describes not one, but four types of sanctioned draft dodgers. 

  מִֽי־הָאִ֞ישׁ אֲשֶׁ֨ר בָּנָ֤ה בַֽיִת־חָדָשׁ֙ וְלֹ֣א חֲנָכ֔וֹ יֵלֵ֖ךְ וְיָשֹׁ֣ב לְבֵית֑וֹ פֶּן־יָמוּת֙ בַּמִּלְחָמָ֔ה וְאִ֥ישׁ אַחֵ֖ר יַחְנְכֶֽנּוּ׃

“Is there anyone who has built a new house but has not dedicated it? Let him go back to his home, lest he die in battle and another dedicate it.

וּמִֽי־הָאִ֞ישׁ אֲשֶׁר־נָטַ֥ע כֶּ֙רֶם֙ וְלֹ֣א חִלְּל֔וֹ יֵלֵ֖ךְ וְיָשֹׁ֣ב לְבֵית֑וֹ פֶּן־יָמוּת֙ בַּמִּלְחָמָ֔ה וְאִ֥ישׁ אַחֵ֖ר יְחַלְּלֶֽנּוּ׃

Is there anyone who has planted a vineyard but has never harvested it? Let him go back to his home, lest he die in battle and another harvest it.

וּמִֽי־הָאִ֞ישׁ אֲשֶׁר־אֵרַ֤שׂ אִשָּׁה֙ וְלֹ֣א לְקָחָ֔הּ יֵלֵ֖ךְ וְיָשֹׁ֣ב לְבֵית֑וֹ פֶּן־יָמוּת֙ בַּמִּלְחָמָ֔ה וְאִ֥ישׁ אַחֵ֖ר יִקָּחֶֽנָּה׃

Is there anyone who has paid the bride-price for a wife, but who has not yet married her? Let him go back to his home, lest he die in battle and another marry her.” 

If you grant all of these exemptions, who will be left to fight?  In 2007, Ehud Barak caused an uproar when he characterised the IDF as the army, which is supposed to be the צבא לכל העם- the army for the entire nation, as the צבא לחצי  העם- the army for half the nation. But that is exactly what would happen here. Between the vineyard planters, the new homeowners, the newlyweds and the coward, everyone would go home!

 

Perhaps we can suggest that Torah is most concerned about soldiers entering battle while still having unfinished business to settle. In each of these areas, the Torah wants us to engage in honest and difficult conversations. A soldier who has  built a new home should be thinking about what kind of home he would like to create when he inhabits it. This entails talking about spirituality, about values, about the kind of conversations we’d like to have in it, about how we will welcome guests and use it for chessed- and what boundaries we will establish for what is not welcome.   These are not easy conversations to conduct, but one thing is certain: by not having these conversations, we leave the results to entropy or momentum, leading to spiritual decay and physical chaos. 

 

Next, there is the vineyard, which is also a place that requires a deliberate plan of action, and  serious conversation. Who was the first person ever to plant a vineyard? That’s right- it was Noach. 

וַיָּ֥חֶל נֹ֖חַ אִ֣ישׁ הָֽאֲדָמָ֑ה וַיִּטַּ֖ע כָּֽרֶם׃

Noah, the tiller of the soil, was the first to plant a vineyard. 

 

Sadly, for Noach, the vineyard proved to be a source of much shame and sorrow.  It tore the family apart, it broke the bond between parent and child as well as siblings, and led the debasement of a once righteous man.

The vineyard is a double edged sword.  On the one hand, it is the source of parnassa in an agrarian society, and even today. Indeed, its chief product, wine, is a source of joy. It is the very instrument whereby we sanctify the Shabbos and Yom Tov, conduct our Seder, name our sons at their bris and bless a union under the chuppah. On the other hand, we cannot forget about the dark side of alcohol, as a source of a lack of moderation and addiction. We have these substances in our shuls, and in our homes. This is another difficult conversation we need to have, especially as our children are getting older, and watching. Is alcohol an occasional indulgence, or a social cornerstone? Is shul a place we go to daven, or the place that boasts the highest concentration of potential drinking buddies? It’s not just alcohol; there are so many other addiction triggers- gambling, excessive or inappropriate internet use, drugs, eating, and the list goes on and on.  Have we ever spoken about how we will tend the vineyard in our lives? How will we reconcile its grave dangers with its wonderful benefits? Our sages tell us that a true hero, a person of might, is someone who is כובש את יצרו- someone who overcomes his evil inclination. If I may, our generation’s charge is not even to overcome our demons, but simply to be brave enough to acknowledge that those demons exist. Will those among us who struggle with any of these issues receive love, support and a non-judgmental attitude from us? The soldier who never had this conversation, or never received assistance, was sent home to settle his vineyard. 

 

Thirdly, there is the newlywed. Here, too, the Torah wanted important conversations to take place prior to engaging in battle. This doesn’t just mean that he hasn’t lived as a married man, but rather  that he hasn’t addressed the uncomfortable yet necessary challenges facing every couple- marital intimacy issues, communication (and the two are so closely related), finances, family and overall spiritual and religious goals they have as a couple. It also means speaking with young couples who are dating or engaged about the critical importance of signing the Halachic Prenuptial Agreement, the one method that preemptively prevents agunah situations with 100% effectively. This agreement prevents men from holding women hostage to a Get, and women and men alike holding each other hostage in a marriage  for financial gain or retribution. Let me state publicly that please God, soon, your children will be getting married. If you would like me to officiate (as well you should!), I will not do so without them signing the prenup first. Another essential conversation is about the importance of genetic testing, to ensure the health of our future children, and of the Jewish people. These are uncomfortable subjects to discuss; they are easier  to avoid in the moment, and costlier to avoid in the long term. The Torah urges us to be open with these conversations, because running to war may appear heroic to the rest of the world, while in fact it may serve as an avoidance tactic. A soldier should not run to save the world without having the conversations to save his marriage. 

Finally, the soldier who is simply afraid is the one who fears death. Rabbeinu Bachya describes this as a dual fear- the fear of killing others, and the fear of dying at their hands. Conversations about the end of life may be among the most unpleasant to contemplate, but are also among the most important. Have we ever spoken about death with our children or with ourselves? Because children do think about death, even if we prefer they didn’t, and even if they’ve been blessed never to confront it directly. One of the healthiest and most age appropriate conversations about mortality I’ve ever heard took place in my own home, conducted by my own wife. It was on Shavuos just a few months ago, during the blackout, and it was past the childrens’ bed time. Avremi really didn’t want to go to bed; this is typical, of course, but this time, he came up with an ingenious stalling tactic. He came into the living room, in tears. Thank God, Avremi is usually a happy child and his thoughts are not  typically dark; he is also not yet four. So Jessica was shocked at his response when she asked him why he was crying. He said, “I’m just going to get older, and older, and then I’m going to die!” Regaining her composure, Jessica gave him a kiss and a hug, and said “Yes, Avremi- that’s right. Hopefully, we all do! Now go to sleep.” Believe it or not, it worked! It’s hard to hear children talk like this, but maybe that’s because most of us are afraid to talk to them about death. And beyond the conversation with children, how many of us have made and periodically updated a will or prepared a halachic health care proxy? Have we made our intentions known regarding our burial, or our funerals? Are we positioning our descendants to unite after our passing, or to descend into rancor and recrimination? Saying that we just want our children to get along without having a conversation about how to make that happen is dangerous wishful thinking. In death, as in life, failure to prepare is preparing to fail (see here for an excellent related post by Rabbi Efrem Goldberg).  

The exemptions from war represent four categories of people who believe that there will always be another opportunity to worry about critical issues.  Whether it is the ruchniyus of the home, dangerous addictions, warning signs in a marriage and end of life preparations, people who fail to address these issues are fundamentally unfit for battle.  How can they fight to preserve the sanctity of life if they are too timid or too lazy to experience real life themselves? How can we expect a show of bravery in theatre of battle from a soldier who is in actuality a coward?

According to the Sfas Emes, venturing out to battle is not a narrative about a soldier- it’s a metaphor for the soul, and the battles we face in the coming weeks and months. It is no accident that this parsha and next week’s, both of which describe battlefield situations, are always read in the month of Elul. Many of us would rather have a root canal without anaesthesia than engage in the kind of introspection and conversation this month demands. What a shame! Elul is a gift, as it puts us in the proper frame of mind to address the challenges that are part of life. On Sunday, September 22, we are hosting three events at Shaare Tefilla that speak to three of these realms. In considering the kind of home we would like to build and the role spirituality should play in it, practice makes perfect and positive peer pressure can be a critical ingredient in our success. The day will begin at 8 AM with our fourth annual Massive Morning Minyan, in memory of Mr. Izrael Becker z”l. This event is open to men and women, and each year, our numbers increase at this remarkable event. It is the last regular Sunday morning tefillah of the year, and the perfect way to start off your week and end off your year. What a powerful impression an event like this can leave on us, and on our children! (There will, of course, be a gala breakfast to follow).  Hopefully, our massive communal participation can engender important discussions in all our homes about the role of communal prayer, the spiritual role of the shul in our lives, and the kind of practical Jewish role modeling we should engage in for our children. 

At 1:30 in the afternoon at Shaare Tefilla in the Beit Midrash, we are facilitating an event called ‘The Conversation.” This is an initiative that has been conducted in houses of worship of all faiths and all denominations of Judaism. It is precisely the fear of the biblical soldier that this event seeks to address, affording participants an opportunity to talk about end of life issues, and providing the tools to formulate directives and plan conversations around these critical topics with ourselves, and our loved ones. (Click here for reservations

Finally, at 8 PM, we are hosting an event at the Enlighten Spa called “Bedroom Botox: Uncovering New Levels of Intimacy In Your Marriage.” A colleague of mine criticized me for talking about this in public, and especially for including the title in a public address. I told him that he was proving my point! We must be able to conduct healthy and appropriate conversations about this subject, and Adina Stilerman is a terrific person to do so. She is a renowned educator and speaker who is especially acclaimed for her sensitive yet candid discussions of intimacy issues. The event is open to women over 21 years of age, but the need for open and honest conversation about this topic applies to all genders and ages, at age appropriate levels (click here to reserve).

I hope you will join us for these events. But even if you don’t, I cannot think of a more perfect moment to engage in the necessary yet uncomfortable conversations in our lives. 

 

Red Herring Judaism- Ekev 5779

The following story is completely true. It was told to me by Rabbi Yaakov Bienenfeld, Rabbi of the Young Israel of Harrison in Westchester County,  who is a legendary Rebbe who taught at the Ramaz Upper School for over two decades. A number of years ago, the students were awaiting a visit from a certain prominent Rabbi that teaches in an Israeli Torah institution.  As a show of respect, a delegation of students was stationed by the door to greet the esteemed guest. The Rabbi , who was wearing slacks, a blue oxford and a knitted kippah, passed by the students unnoticed and headed immediately up to the office, to prepare for his address to the student body and for the interviews he was about to conduct for his post High School program. Meanwhile, at around the same time, another man showed up with a long beard, flowing payos and a long frock coat and hat. Instantly, the students ushered him into the assembly and broke out into ecstatic song, אור זרוע לצדיק ולישרי לב שמחה! A group of boys began dancing around him as everyone rose to their feet as he entered the packed room. The man looked rather befuddled, and turned to Rabbi Bienenfeld, asking “Why are they dancing me in like this?” Rabbi Bienenfeld replied, “I don’t know! What brings you here?” The man said, “I’m here to restock the vending machine!”

 

What sort of assumptions and cultural conditioning lead to this kind of misunderstanding? 

 

Perhaps the most  misunderstood religious symbol from our time in the midbar is that miraculous bread which fell from the heavens – the מן. 

According to the Torah, the man was not merely a spiritual phenomenon, but one with a very specific goal in mind – to test us:

דברים פרק ח

(ב) וְזָכַרְתָּ֣ אֶת־כָּל־הַדֶּ֗רֶךְ אֲשֶׁ֨ר הוֹלִֽיכֲךָ֜ יְקֹוָ֧ק אֱלֹהֶ֛יךָ זֶ֛ה אַרְבָּעִ֥ים שָׁנָ֖ה בַּמִּדְבָּ֑ר לְמַ֨עַן עַנֹּֽתְךָ֜ לְנַסֹּֽתְךָ֗ לָדַ֜עַת אֶת־אֲשֶׁ֧ר בִּֽלְבָבְךָ֛ הֲתִשְׁמֹ֥ר מצותו מִצְוֹתָ֖יו אִם־לֹֽא: 

 

What kind of test is the man? The Gemara informs us that is was a magical food that tasted like whatever your heart desired, that it fell every day like clockwork and required no effort to obtain.  For this blessed period of forty years the Jewish children were not subject to the curse of בזעת אפך תאכל לחם – by the sweat of your brow shall you consume bread. If so, what is the meaning of   לְמַ֨עַן עַנֹּֽתְךָ֜ לְנַסֹּֽתְךָ֗ ? Where is the inuy, or deprivation, and the nisayon, the test, in that? How can the Torah possibly use the same word to describe the akeidah as it does to describe heavenly food? 

 

The Ramban says that the ענוי was having to live with a new sort of food – one which was unfamiliar to them and their ancestors.

רמב”ן דברים פרק ח פסוק ג

(ג) וטעם אשר לא ידעת ולא ידעון אבתיך – כי לא ידעת במן שתוכלו לחיות בו ימים רבים, ולא הגיע אליכם כן בקבלה מאבותיכם. 

The most comforting food a person can eat is food that reminds them of home-the kind of food that tends to feature prominently in eulogies. “Grandma  Muriel- she made the best noodle kugel! In her final moments she froze 12 pieces of kugel for each of her grandchildren to remember her…” However, man was a new food, a new reality, such that the Jewish people had no sense of its ability to sustain them. This was the test – to develop a relationship of Hashem in the absence of nostalgia and the empty symbolism food represented.  He wanted to bring us to a place in which we viewed food as a vehicle for faith, not as a value for life. 

 

This presents us with an ironic challenge – for though everything we do is steeped in tradition and memory, there are moments in which maintaining a religious identity demands that we look past markers of cultural identification.  The very things we thought anchored us to community and the values of the previous generation may be detrimental to true faith.

The chassidishe vendor in our opening story was no doubt a God fearing man trying to support his family honorably. In my high school, we’d have danced him in because he was about to restock the potato chips! But the Ramaz students associated his appearance with Torah and a life of authentic religious commitment, so they assumed he must be the Rosh Yeshiva, and danced him in. When being “Jewish” is a matter of culture alone, and nothing more than connecting to roots, we run the risk of becoming superficially devout,  or judging piety based on outward appearances. Not everything done “in the alta heim” is blessed and glorious, and we mustn’t confuse antiquity with authenticity. Remember the disgruntled tribes of Israel bone of contention with the man was:

ולא הגיע אליכם כן בקבלה מאבותיכם

They dismissed this new item because it didn’t give them that warm and fuzzy feeling.  Our sense of self and religious identity is so wrapped up in the past, that we forget to be עובדי ה in the present.

We are especially vulnerable to this mentality when it comes to food, because  we have constructed outsized narratives of heritage through our relationship to it.  It makes us feel authentic, and gives us a sense that through the food we eat, we are involved in an act of transcendence. This is why Kosher food instagrammers enjoy near celebrity status, and pages of frum publications feature increasingly elaborate recipes and ever more intricate and expensive table settings.   

Let me state unequivocally that I am the last person to criticize this. First of all, there is nothing wrong with delicious kosher food set on a beautiful table; quite the opposite- kosher food should be just as appealing as its treif counterpart, if not moreso. Also, I’m a foodie Rabbi who likes to cook exotic dishes as much as Jessica hates eating them…  But remember, that even our food is not merely a cultural feature but rather a religious one. For example, every Jewish ethnic group has some variant of an overnight Shabbos dish. For Ashkenazim it’s Cholent, Sephardim- Hamin, Yemenites have kubaneh and the list goes on. This is not because they ate it in some shtetel, but because of a comment of Rabbeinu Zerachya HaLevi (the Baal HaMeor) on Tractate Shabbos who explained that we are required to distance ourselves from the erroneous belief of the Karaites who felt that it was forbidden to enjoy any hot food on Shabbat.  

תקנת רבותינו היא לענג את השבת בחמין

 וכל מי שאינו אוכל חמין – צריך בדיקה אחריו אם הוא מין… 

ולהזמין לבשל להטמין, ולענג את השבת ולהשמין – 

הוא המאמין וזוכה לקץ הימין

To paraphrase:

Our Rabbis said Shabbos food must be served hot,

You might be a heretic if in fact it is not

Prepare the food and gain a few pounds- or a lot,

And your eternal reward will be more than you thought

….

The reason cholent is a marker of a Jewish home is that Shabbos observance is a marker of a Jewish home! 

A most fascinating example of peddling in tropes of authenticity is a recent delicious culinary craze to sweep the east coast, occasionally available at The Kosher Palate – The Rebbe’s Choice Herring. This product line features half a dozen or so varieties of herrings and other appetizers,  each flavor inspired by a different Chassidishe Rebbe.

For example, there is the Herring of Kotzk, a honey mustard sriracha blend designed to evoke the fiery temperament of the Kotzker Rebbe,  or Sweet Black Pepper herring, named after Rav Levi Yitzchak of Berditchev, or smokey Zaatar, inspired by Rav Zusha of Anipoli Not to be outdone, Flaum’s Fish started a rival line called the Herring of Volozhin, using the analytical terminology of Rav Chaim of Brisk:

“A Herring that is Gavra and Cheftza — uniting subject and object…”

This whole premise is laughable- a red herring, if you will.  Many of these Rebbes after whom the herring is named were spit poor, and probably never had herring. If they did, it definitely did not feature sriracha or Jalapeno. It was probably plain herring, served hastily between pogroms. The flames of conflict between Chassidic and the Lithuanian worlds are once again being fanned- this time in our digestive tracts. 

The shame of it is that these glorious traditions and dynasties have so much to teach us that has nothing to do with food. Authenticity is gut-wrenching work, because it entails looking inward and becoming the type of person our symbols project. Watching Shtisel and other Israeli programming is not a sufficient expression of Zionism, although I do plan on offering a series in the fall exploring some of the Torah themes in this amazing show. If you want to be inspired by R’ Zusha, it is not smokey Zaatar- it is praying with fervor and passion, without the distraction of a cell phone.  If you want a taste of Volozhin, look in a bookcase, not a refrigerator, and open a Nefesh HaChaim or the commentary of the Netziv. If you want to be inspired by Kotzk, work on uncompromising honesty with oneself and with others. If you wish to be inspired by R Levi Yitzchak, give every Jew the benefit of the doubt, no matter how they vote, where they daven and whether they wear a bekeshe or a blue oxford shirt…and maybe even dance them in to the room.  

 

©2019 Rabbi Ariel Rackovsky and Rabbi Shaanan Gelman